Long Island Wins provides resources and insight to promote
immigration solutions that include and work for everyone.

Features

Home > Features > Undocumented Student Dreams of Higher Education, But Doesn’t Know If It’s Possible

Latest Post

Undocumented Student Dreams of Higher Education, But Doesn’t Know If It’s Possible

Undocumented Student Dreams of Higher Education, But Doesn’t Know If It’s Possible

Posted July 20, 2010 by David Sperling, Esq.

Share

In “The Answer Man” series, David Sperling, Esq., fields reader questions about immigration law.


Question

I am a 17-year-old high school student in Bay Shore. My parents brought me here from Colombia when I was 8 years old. I want to go to college, but I have no papers. I can’t even get a driver’s license. I’ve heard about the DREAM Act. Will that help?


Answer   

Yes, if the bill ever becomes a law. The DREAM Act was first introduced in 2003, but has always been considered a part of a comprehensive immigration reform package. Now, with the increasingly bleak prospect of wholesale reform being passed anytime in the near future, many advocates are focusing on the DREAM Act as an immediate down payment on the Obama administration’s promise of immigration reform.

The measure, which has gained some bipartisan support, would allow immigrants who entered the United States before age 15 the opportunity to gain legal status after completing two years of college or service in the armed forces. The idea is that young people should not be punished because their parents entered or remained in the United States without authorization. The DREAM Act would benefit hundreds of thousands of young people, including yourself.
       
What to do now? Even without a Social Security number, you can attend college and graduate school. You will not be eligible for government grants or loans, although you may be eligible for in-state tuition for CUNY and SUNY colleges, which is significantly more affordable than out-of-state tuition. The problem is that upon graduation you cannot practice any profession without having legal status.

You did not indicate whether you entered the United States legally with a visa or illegally without inspection. There is a big difference. If you entered legally and can prove it with an old passport or by filing an I-102 application to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services’ center in Vermont, you will always have the opportunity to get your green card through a bona fide marriage to a US citizen (I only provide the legal strategy; the rest is up to you).

If you entered with your parents illegally, there is also an option that could work, but if it fails, you may be stuck outside of the US.

You could return to Colombia before you turn 18 years and six months old, and apply for a student visa at the US Embassy in Bogota. If approved, you will get a a visa for the duration of your studies, and limited work authorization, after which a US company can sponsor you for an H-1B professional visa good for an additional six years. While in H-1B status, your company could sponsor you for an employment-based green card. And during all that time, you could always meet the US citizen woman of your dreams.

Why 18 years and six months? One of the more draconian elements of immigration law is the 10-year bar for immigrants who reside unlawfully in the United States for a year or longer and then voluntarily leave. After leaving the United States, they cannot re-enter legally for 10 years without a special waiver that would be virtually impossible for anyone without a US citizen spouse. Fortunately, unlawful presence does not accrue until you turn 18 years old. So if you leave before six months after your 18th birthday, you would avoid a similar 3-year bar.

If you consider this option, do your homework and visit the college. Speak to the administration officials in charge of foreign students to give you a better idea of embassy approval rates. Because if your visa is denied, you are stuck in Colombia. 

If neither of these options are feasible, I would strongly urge you to consider attending college even without papers. It will be another seven or eight years before you get your master’s degree. During that time, there is an excellent chance that the DREAM Act and comprehensive immigration reform will pass. Don’t wait around and put your life on hold. Follow your dreams and you won’t be sorry. 


DISCLAIMER

In this column, Long Island Wins provides information about immigration law designed to help users understand and navigate the immigration system. The information contained on Long Island Wins is provided to you “as is,” and does not constitute legal advice. We are not acting as your attorney. Furthermore, statements in this column are not to be construed as legal advice creating an attorney-client relationship. Anyone with an immigration issue is strongly advised to consult with an experienced attorney or reputable non-profit legal-services organization.


Image courtesy of Schlüsselbein2007 via Flickr.


Tags : answer man, colombia, dream act, undocumented students


Comments

Media Mentions

Some minority voters worried about redistricting
February 7, 2012
Minority groups dismiss redistricting plan
February 7, 2012
Are New York Voters of Color Getting a Fair Shake?
February 7, 2012
Letter: ‘Land of the Free and Home of the Brave; Do We Still Believe It?’
February 3, 2012
Long Island forum offers opportunity to weigh in on redistricting
February 2, 2012
Forum: Redistricting and Its Impact on Long Island Communities of Color
February 1, 2012
Archila: Electoral maps cheat minorities
February 1, 2012
LI WINS: MEET NASSAU COUNTY LEGISLATOR CARRIÉ SOLAGES
January 24, 2012
Families fight banks for loan modifications
January 24, 2012
Our Shadow Population (Part I)
January 17, 2012
LI WINS: STEVE LEVY’S LEGACY ON IMMIGRATION
January 6, 2012
Voter fraud is not a big problem in U.S.
December 23, 2011
From Civil War to Public Service
December 19, 2011
Sharing the Good News This Holiday Season
December 19, 2011
Letter: Lucero lawsuit is very important
December 14, 2011
Surprise! Nassau Bus Deal Was Rotten
December 13, 2011
Hundreds protest MTA bus privatization plan
December 12, 2011
TED HESSON: SURPRISE! NASSAU BUS DEAL WAS ROTTEN
December 12, 2011
DREAM Act team turns to state aid
December 8, 2011
When government audits, immigrants lose
December 1, 2011
Study notes immigrants’ role in LI economy
October 27, 2011
Immigrants fuel LI economy
October 27, 2011
Study Finds That Immigrants Are Central to Long Island Economy
October 27, 2011
“Occupy Wall Street” media wrap-up #3
October 27, 2011
Brother of hate crime victim fights back
October 27, 2011
Battles over mosques are on the rise
October 19, 2011
QueensLatino founder discusses Latino Media Conference
October 19, 2011
Coalition mobilizing African American and Latino voters
October 17, 2011
LGBT immigrants feel discrimination twice
October 17, 2011
Why a Latino media conference?
October 11, 2011
Hempstead Fire Department drops policy barring non-citizens
October 4, 2011
Suffolk police failing residents
October 4, 2011
Dancing—a science, business, and art for Alfred Peña
October 4, 2011
Victory! The Department of Justice Appeals Ruling on Alabama’s Extreme Immigration Law
October 4, 2011
LI Wins on Rhythmology
October 4, 2011
Suffolk Police Failing Residents With Limited English, Need Meaningful Changes [VIDEO]
September 29, 2011
Interview: Sonia Nazario Discusses Enrique’s Journey and Child Migrants (AUDIO SLIDESHOW)
September 28, 2011
Otro paso contra crímenes de odio
September 16, 2011
LI immigrant advocates applaud DOJ letter
September 15, 2011
At Restaurant Born After 9/11, Respect for Worker Rights
September 13, 2011
Post-9/11 restaurant respects workers rights
September 13, 2011
No Peace in National Immigration Debate
August 24, 2011
A Marine Discovers Islam in Iraq
August 22, 2011
The Recession
August 19, 2011
New Yorkers Register Concerns with Obama on “Secure Communities”
August 16, 2011
A Hate Crimes Commander Laid To Rest in Suffolk, But Questions Remain
August 11, 2011
El poder político de los latinos comienza por casa
August 10, 2011
Behind the Walls of an Immigration Detention Center in Florence, Arizona [VIDEO]
August 2, 2011
Crisis humanitaria, en pleno suelo americano
July 11, 2011
GUESTWORDS: Border Trouble
July 8, 2011
Corrupt Suffolk County Executive Steve Levy Takes Aim at Immigrant Workers
June 6, 2011
“Secure Communities” & “English Only” Terminated in NY
June 3, 2011
No More Deaths: The Crisis on the U.S.- Mexico Border in Arizona
May 25, 2011
Play: ‘What Killed Lucero’ Has Patchogue Premiere
April 29, 2011
Tense But Respectful Dialogue as Killer’s Father Speaks at Play About Slain Ecuadorian Immigrant
April 28, 2011
Controversial Play Put On In Patchogue
April 26, 2011
Play about Lucero’s death raises questions
April 26, 2011
Kids Are Collateral Damage From Our Broken Immigration System
April 22, 2011
How an American Preschooler Ended Up a Deportee in Guatemala
April 14, 2011
Four Year-Old American Emily Ruiz Attempts Re-Entry From Guatemala, Again
April 14, 2011
US Children Obligated To Live Outside the Country [En Español]
April 11, 2011
Guatemalan Girl Successfully Returned to the US (En Español)
March 29, 2011
NY politician suggests Levy consider resigning
March 25, 2011
County Reps Get Low Grades on Immigration Issues
August 5, 2010
Ecuatoriana sin papeles teme perder a su hijo
August 5, 2010
Lawmakers Score ‘C’ on Immigration
August 3, 2010
In Port Jefferson, Rallies Over Arizona Law
August 2, 2010
Conroy trial: It’s in the jury’s hands
April 14, 2010
Send a Message of Support to Joselo Lucero
March 30, 2010
Immigration Reform Works for Everyone
March 17, 2010
Dozens Rally Outside Schumer’s Office for Immigration Reform
March 8, 2010
LI WINS loses whacks on Levy
February 1, 2010
Nassau Police chief reassures immigrants
December 2, 2009
Suozzi speaks at immigration forum
November 17, 2009
Levy’s office follows rules on critics
September 6, 2009
Get Involved
Visit the Action Center to find out how you can effect change in your community.
Learn More
See the Media & Resources available to help you get the facts about immigration on Long Island.
Support Long Island Wins
Your donations and financial support keep us going. Every bit helps. Donate today!
Connect with Us
Stay Informed!